Lebanese protests challenge Hezbollah’s hold on Shia base

"Now Hezbollah is being “attacked by the very constituency they purport to speak for,” said Heiko Wimmen of the International Crisis Group.
Tuesday 19/11/2019
 In this Oct. 25, 2019 file photo, supporters of Hezbollah leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah hold his pictures and waves Hezbollah flags in the southern suburb of Beirut, Lebanon. (AP)
In this Oct. 25, 2019 file photo, supporters of Hezbollah leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah hold his pictures and waves Hezbollah flags in the southern suburb of Beirut, Lebanon. (AP)

BEIRUT - Young men chanting the "people want to bring down the regime" gathered outside the office of Lebanese legislator Mohammed Raad, the powerful head of Hezbollah's parliamentary bloc. One shirtless man grabbed a metal rod and swung it at the sign bearing Raad’s name, knocking it out of place as others cheered.

It was a rare scene in the southern market town of Nabatiyeh, a Hezbollah stronghold. The protests engulfing Lebanon have united many across sectarian lines and shattered taboos, with some taking aim at leaders from their own sects, illustrating a new, unfamiliar challenge posed to Hezbollah.

Iran-backed Hezbollah has tried to build a reputation among supporters as a champion of the poor and a defender of Lebanon against Israel's much more powerful military. It and its Shia ally, the Amal Movement, have enjoyed overwhelming backing among the Shia community since the end of the 1975-90 civil war, making them a political powerhouse that, along with allies, has dominated recent governments.

Many protesters, however, group Hezbollah into the ruling class they are revolting against, blaming it for wrecking Lebanon’s economy with years of corruption and mismanagement.

Protesters want that entire political elite out. Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah and parliament Speaker Nabih Berri, Amal’s chairman, have not been spared.

"All of them means all of them and Nasrallah is one of them," protesters chanted at Beirut rallies. The demonstrations that erupted October 17 spread throughout the country, including predominantly Shia areas in the south and the eastern Bekaa Valley.

“The heavy participation of the Shias... posed a main challenge. That there's a large number from the sect that doesn’t accept the current situation,” said Hilal Khashan, professor of political science at the American University of Beirut. “That's why there was a swift and decisive decision to nip this in the bud.”

In several instances, men suspected of being Hezbollah and Amal supporters beat protesters and destroyed their tents. Some of those who criticised Nasrallah and Berri on social media appeared in videos, after apparently being beaten, to apologise for what they did.

Amal denied any link to those behind the beatings, saying in a statement that they should be arrested and that they violated the movement’s belief in freedom of opinion.

Hezbollah has survived many threats over the past years, including charges by a UN-backed tribunal for the killing of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in February 2005 -- an accusation Hezbollah strongly denies -- a ruinous war with Israel in 2006 and the war in neighbouring Syria, where Hezbollah has sent thousands of fighters to back Syrian President Bashar Assad, losing an estimated 2,000 men.

Now Hezbollah is being “attacked by the very constituency they purport to speak for,” Heiko Wimmen of the International Crisis Group said.

Hezbollah is “on the defensive for having become part or the ruling elite, which is clearly a disconcerting experience for the leadership,” he said, though he noted anger is far stronger at Amal, whose leader Berri has been directly entrenched in politics for decades.

Hassan, a protester from the southern city of Tyre, said he supports Hezbollah’s “resistance” against Israel, calling it a “red line” that must not be undermined but its other policies are a different story.

"The party... has been silent about the symbols of corruption with the logic that we don't want a civil war, but these policies have hurt the south," Hassan said, asking to be identified by one name, citing security reasons.

Protesters in Nabatiyeh joined those elsewhere in the country in banging pots and pans in protest; some cried “Against poverty and against hunger, the people are all in pain,” videos posted online show.

An activist from Nabatiyeh, who asked to be identified as Abdel-Jaleel, distanced protesters from those who attacked the Hezbollah lawmaker’s office in the town, whom he called “troublemakers,” but he said the demand for change -- despite support for the “resistance” -- was real among a new generation growing up to find few jobs or little hope.

Hezbollah has sought to show it’s sensitive to the complaints. Nasrallah recently said in a speech that authorities investigating corruption should start with looking at Hezbollah members. "Begin with us," he said.

Hezbollah’s popularity has stemmed from a vast array of services, through education, health and social networks. It says it’s still able to maintain that network despite intensified sanctions by Washington, which designates Hezbollah as a terrorist organisation.

Wimmen, like other observers, said Hezbollah is strong enough to survive because its base is largely cohesive and “the resistance narrative still works.”

However, it can’t ignore the alienation over economic woes, he said, and it is “short on solutions.”

Nasrallah has tried to walk a fine line. In speeches, he expressed sympathy for protesters’ demands but also accused foreign powers of exploiting them to undermine his group and warned against dragging the country into civil war. Some Shias who initially joined demonstrations stayed away after the speeches.

Hardcore Hezbollah supporters and some officials contend that the United States, some Arab Gulf countries and other rival nations are trying to take advantage of the protests to undermine the group.

Senior Hezbollah official Sheikh Ali Daamoush said the group differentiates between protesters’ legitimate demands and those with agendas who “want to take advantage of the protests to achieve political goals that are not in Lebanon's interest."

Hezbollah’s core supporters will stick by it but the group risks “potentially losing the Shia community's absolute representation,” said Joe Macaron of the Arab Centre Washington DC.

On a recent day when Associated Press journalists visited Hezbollah's southern Beirut stronghold of Dahiyeh -- accompanied by a Hezbollah guide -- there was no sign of the turmoil and paralysis gripping the rest of the country. Streets teemed with cars, a man in a uniform picked up trash as men and women, some in overflowing black abayas, others in jeans, passed by.

There is, however, sympathy for some of the protesters’ complaints.

"There are legislators who are stealing. There are officials who are stealing. People will rise against you," resident Ali Sharafeddine said, even as he expressed respect for Nasrallah and Berri.

Mohamed Harb said he understood the economic hardships driving protesters. Everything has become expensive, he said. Working at a hospital, he recently took a second job selling vegetables and still struggles to make ends meet.

Still, he remains unequivocal in his support for Hezbollah and Nasrallah.

"Hezbollah means everything to me," he said. Of Nasrallah “tells us to go die, we go die.”

(Associated Press)